Disagreement Is Not Destruction: The Difference Between Criticism and Intolerance
Recent public demonstrations involving the tearing and discarding of pages from a published literary work have brought an important question into focus: When did disagreement with an idea become a justification for destroying its expression? You may disagree with an author's interpretation of history, reject the ideology presented in a book, question its arguments or find its contents deeply objectionable. You are entitled to every one of those responses. But does disagreement give you the authority to destroy what you cannot accept? If you don't like a book, don't read it. Nobody is forcing you to. You are perfectly entitled to disagree with its contents, question its arguments, criticise its ideas or simply ignore it. That is your freedom. But tearing up a book is not an expression of disagreement; it is an act of disrespect towards the work, the creative process and the people who invested their thoughts, time and effort in bringing it into existence. A bo...